The Empty House

English: Second of the four illustrations incl...

English: Second of the four illustrations included in the edition of Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes by AC Doyle published in 1894 by A. L. Burt in New York. (Source: Wikipedia)

Sherlock, season 3 begins on PBS tonight. In anticipation, I’ve read “The Empty House,” the Arthur Conan Doyle (ACD) short story that the episode is based on. It’s been years since I’ve read a Sherlock story. When I was in high school, I was in the Sherlock Holmes Society and read several. Doyle knows how to tell a good story. His style is direct and compelling. His hero, Sherlock is brilliant yet flawed and he captures the friendship between Holmes and Watson very well. They’re able to speak frankly, though Watson sometimes refrains from commenting because he feels he won’t be listened to or in other cases, is in awe of his friend’s mental prowess.

“The Empty House” was the first story of Holmes’ return or resurrection. Fans will remember that Doyle grew tired of his popular character. Apparently, ACD suffered more than Watson from being overshadowed by Sherlock. Try as he might, he wanted Sherlock gone, but the public clamored for more and after 10 years, ACD relented and wrote, “The Empty House” in which Sherlock returns to solve the case of the murder of Ronald Adair.

Highlights include Sherlock explaining how and why he cheated death and fooled Moriarty and Watson holding what might be the first literary intervention when he voices disproval of Sherlock’s use of (the then legal) cocaine. Like the modern Sherlock played by Benedict Cumberbatch, the original Sherlock used stimulants to stave off the boredom of ordinary life.

I delighted in how often Sherlock quotes Shakespeare and recommend getting an annotated book like The Oxford Sherlock Holmes, which illuminates all the references and quotations.

Reading the story this time around, I was struck by how much screenwriters Moffat and Gatiss borrow from the original. I’m not complaining. In fact I applaud them for their faithful, clever adaptations.

Tonight American fans  see what the duo has done to explain Sherlock’s death. How could he fake his death so convincingly? The YouTube video above provides a thoughtful analysis. If it’s correct, Moffat and Gatiss would have closely followed what happened in the original story. Folks in the U.K. already know what happened. In North America we’ll soon find out.

Do read the originals. They’re well written and you’ll gain insight. For next week I’m finishing The Sign of Four.

6 thoughts on “The Empty House

  1. I love Sherlock Holmes and have watched every adaptation. Have you seen “Elementary” with Lucy Liu and Johnny Lee Miller? I really like it. It’s interesting to have the Cumberbatch and Miller versions on at the same time. But the quintessential Sherlock, for me, was Jeremy Brett.
    Thanks for visiting and liking my post! Gail


    • I agree that the Jeremy Brett Sherlock is quintessential and I find I believe he “really is” Sherlock. Next I’d say is a tie between the modern Cumberbatch and Basil Rathbone. I’ve seen Johnny Lee Miller’s Elementary and didn’t like it last year. It just didn’t seem right as it’s very tied to the CBS formula. Yet I gave it another chance last night and though it was better. I think CBS demands writers stick to a specific formula that works for programs like CSI.


  2. Pingback: Sherlock: Season 3, Episode 1 | Ruined for Life: Phoenix Edition

  3. Pingback: Sherlock: Season 3, Episode 1 | Mixed Media

Comments are closed.